Welcome Guest! To enable all features please Login or Register.

Notification

Icon
Error

Forum Jump  
Core Audio Overload using EXS
Last post Tue, Nov 30 2004 by JohnA, 22 replies.
Options
Go to last post
2 Pages12>
Posted on Sun, Nov 21 2004 18:55
by rickmusik
Joined on Sun, Nov 21 2004, Posts 4
using logic 7 g5 dual2 i get core overload on the first play through of a logic song using say 24 audio exs instruments mainly vienna library..

cpu use is about 25% ram use about 1 gig of 1.5 gig

once insruments have played through once logic behaves...

I have to play back the whole logic song stopping at each new section which stops with a core overload alert box then on replaying from the top it is ok why?
Posted on Sun, Nov 21 2004 19:21
by evan evans
Joined on Tue, Jun 17 2003, Hollywood, CA, Posts 2058
God. We don't know why. But it's true, that is a problem.

OFFLINE bounce works though.

Evan Evans
Evan Evans
Film Scoring Academy
http://filmscoring.academy
Posted on Sun, Nov 21 2004 19:37
by Ned Bouhalassa
Joined on Sat, Mar 13 2004, Montreal, Posts 16
Same problem here. Logic 7 + Dual 2Ghz. Crying
Posted on Mon, Nov 22 2004 15:35
by michael.matthews
Joined on Sat, Aug 23 2003, Montréal / Berlin, Posts 286
I consistently have this problem. It is so irritatiing that I now leave my computer running overnight (with my Logic and Finale files open) when I am working on a project so that I do not have to "prime" the samples again.

Does anybody at VSL have any theories about this?

Michael Matthews
Posted on Mon, Nov 22 2004 17:12
by Nick Batzdorf
Joined on Tue, Apr 29 2003, Los Angeles, Posts 2546
Maybe 1.5 GB isn't enough now?
Mac Pro 5,1 12-core 3.46 GHz, 64MB RAM, latest macOS available. Metric Halo 2882 interface.

VisionDAW Windows 7 Pro i7 950 3.07 4-core, 24GB RAM. Has an RME Hammerfall HDSP9632, but I just use VE Pro. Also several ancient P4 XP slaves, rarely used.
Posted on Mon, Nov 22 2004 18:11
by drg
Joined on Sun, Oct 31 2004, Palm Beach, Florida, Posts 33
I'm experiencing the same thing with 4GB RAM.
Posted on Mon, Nov 22 2004 19:55
by Nick Batzdorf
Joined on Tue, Apr 29 2003, Los Angeles, Posts 2546
Takes care of that theory... Smile
Mac Pro 5,1 12-core 3.46 GHz, 64MB RAM, latest macOS available. Metric Halo 2882 interface.

VisionDAW Windows 7 Pro i7 950 3.07 4-core, 24GB RAM. Has an RME Hammerfall HDSP9632, but I just use VE Pro. Also several ancient P4 XP slaves, rarely used.
Posted on Mon, Nov 22 2004 23:38
by Sandpiper
Joined on Wed, May 28 2003, Cumbria UK, Posts 74
This is what happens in my tests mentioned in my thread about measuring RAM usage when using EXS.

My observation on the subject of swap files, active and free memory seemed to show that sample headers being loaded were passed to swap files when memory usage was above a certain level BUT that there was Free and Available memory still listed - the default is 1 swap file although you can "delete" this with certain utilities. How the system decides what to page out is I believe beyond our control but once you invoke play then gradually those sample headers get put back into RAM and presumably other data (part of Logic or system) get put out to swap files. You can then play without the dreaded Core Audio overload in those situations where you are "close to the limit" which with 1.5 GIG in my case was showing 485MB free. Does anyone know what is "ring fencing" that 485 MB as presumably not being available for sample headers ie preventing its immediate use?

I haven't double checked those numbers tonight but I think I am in the general area.

Note: if loading instruments manually as you build an instrument set, I think there does not appear to be as great an occurance of the overload situation compared to if you load a file with them already set up.

What I was looking for in that recent thread was statisics on swap file usage with 4 GIG of RAM. Simply does it go above 1 when loading instruments such as those I listed?

Confused

Stuart
Posted on Tue, Nov 23 2004 02:06
by drg
Joined on Sun, Oct 31 2004, Palm Beach, Florida, Posts 33
As musicians first, which I hope we all are, we shouldn't have to deal with 'swap' files and the like. Our goal is to make music - the technology should enable us to accomplish this in as transparent a manner as possible. The 'Core Audio Overload" problem is a bug and should be corrected by Emagic/Apple. It goes away by simply checking 'Continue' and initiating a Replay. After the initial event, the nasty reminder hasn't reappeared in the same session, i.e., until the next 'fresh' session.[/list]
Posted on Tue, Nov 23 2004 08:41
by Sandpiper
Joined on Wed, May 28 2003, Cumbria UK, Posts 74
drg wrote:
As musicians first, which I hope we all are, we shouldn't have to deal with 'swap' files and the like. Our goal is to make music - the technology should enable us to accomplish this in as transparent a manner as possible. The 'Core Audio Overload" problem is a bug and should be corrected by Emagic/Apple. It goes away by simply checking 'Continue' and initiating a Replay. After the initial event, the nasty reminder hasn't reappeared in the same session, i.e., until the next 'fresh' session.[/list]


I agree with that. In the days when I was using boxes (Proteus 2 etc) it seems it was only polyphony that got in the way. The other day I re-scored an item that was originally done with Proteus sounds with VSL. Proteus now sounds more like a child's toy.

Longing for the day when issues like those in this thread are a thing of the past.



Confused

Stuart
Posted on Tue, Nov 23 2004 12:13
by Patrick Wilson
Joined on Mon, Feb 16 2004, UK, Posts 109
I would like to add that there seems to be a similar 'Overload' problem when using the DTDM Audio engine within Logic. I would be most interested to hear from any others who use VSL in this way (ie. EXS instruments + DTDM audio) and experience error messages like "DTDM audio overload' and such-like.

Another problem is that freezing tracks makes the 'overload' message appear even more frequently.

Another problem I've encountered is notes cutting short. The problem is temporarily solved by opening the 'Virtual Memory' settings page in EXS24 and simply resetting a parameter such as from 'Hard Disk Recording Activity - 'Extensive' to 'Average' or visa-versa. It doesn't seem to make the slightest difference how I set these parameters because it seems to only be a temporary solution.

Since I pawned the family silver to get 6.5 gigs of RAM (G5 dual 2.5) I hope that's not a problem.

I agree that as musicians, we shouldn't have to be speculating about swap files and the like. Unfortunately it would seem that if we want to use their product in a more 'demanding' manner than most people presumably do, then we do have to be prepared to 'take a look under the hood' and get to grips with a little engine tweaking. I'm all ears, spanner in hand.
Posted on Tue, Nov 23 2004 12:46
by KMuzzey
Joined on Tue, Jul 22 2003, Los Angeles, CA, Posts 270
I have some consistent crashes with Logic Pro 7 as well, although not specific to VSL. It turned out that Altiverb needed a fix -- is it possible you're using Altiverb, and that may be the problem? It was causing core audio overload + subsequent crash. If that's the case, you may want to email the Audioease support guys. Just a thought.

Kerry
Posted on Thu, Nov 25 2004 12:51
by Patrick Wilson
Joined on Mon, Feb 16 2004, UK, Posts 109
Re Possible Core Audio Overload cure:

I just called a Logic support guy here who said that a fellow (I think a keyboard player with Genesis) was getting this error message all the time on a laptop and turned off 'Journaling' on his system drive (you have to boot with the original disk to do this). This apparently totally cured the problem.

Anyone tried this?
Posted on Thu, Nov 25 2004 13:07
by Sandpiper
Joined on Wed, May 28 2003, Cumbria UK, Posts 74
Patrick Wilson wrote:
Re Possible Core Audio Overload cure:

I just called a Logic support guy here who said that a fellow (I think a keyboard player with Genesis) was getting this error message all the time on a laptop and turned off 'Journaling' on his system drive (you have to boot with the original disk to do this). This apparently totally cured the problem.

Anyone tried this?


....however 'Journaling' is not relevant in OS 10.2.8 and that is where my experiance lies.

Stuart
Posted on Thu, Nov 25 2004 18:45
by drg
Joined on Sun, Oct 31 2004, Palm Beach, Florida, Posts 33
Patrick Wilson wrote:


....Since I pawned the family silver to get 6.5 gigs of RAM (G5 dual 2.5) I hope that's not a problem.

I agree that as musicians, we shouldn't have to be speculating about swap files and the like. Unfortunately it would seem that if we want to use their product in a more 'demanding' manner than most people presumably do, then we do have to be prepared to 'take a look under the hood' and get to grips with a little engine tweaking. I'm all ears, spanner in hand.


Hi Patrick,

I think Herb and his team have gone a long way toward producing a product that musicians can use. I don't mind tweaking the Performance Tool but it's a real hassle trying to diagnose a problem and then have to tweak something the software developers should have included as an 'automatic', background task. After all these years my arm is getting freakin' tired of holding the spanner.

One closing piece of advice - pawning the family silver is a tough thing to do but never pawn the family jewels - they come in very handy in this business!
Posted on Fri, Nov 26 2004 11:46
by Patrick Wilson
Joined on Mon, Feb 16 2004, UK, Posts 109
Thanks for the advice. Well, we don't have any family jewels anyway!
Probably like you I have been working with constantly buggy software for years starting way back with Cubase XT and early ProTools systems - before that it was giant 24 track machines - reals of expensive 2" tape etc. I had my 24 track machine in the hall of my house (no room in studio). Why any visitors didn't lose their fingers when I was fast rewinding I'll never know. I am inured to trying to get my head around the technicalities and also the fact that the software companies use us as unpaid quality control staff. Anyway we might as well make hay while the sun shines.. Apple are probably, as we speak, working on a program that replaces the musician!
Posted on Fri, Nov 26 2004 18:24
by drg
Joined on Sun, Oct 31 2004, Palm Beach, Florida, Posts 33
I have been working with 'music' software since 1985, then using a'Voyetra' sequencer, a PC running DOS 2.0, DX7 and an 8-bit Emu sampler. I, too, later jumped into a Pro Tools 4-track system.

Down here in Florida,I've been in small Clubs where a guy comes in - sets up his speakers and mixer, plugs in his keyboard - boots up his laptop and 'presto/chango' we have the one-man band. The kids love it - they go nuts - so do I, but for a different reason.

Excuse me but now I have to leave 'old fart land' and return to my music - spanner in hand.
Posted on Sun, Nov 28 2004 13:31
by JohnA
Joined on Fri, Mar 28 2003, Dartmouth, Canada, Posts 161
It is possible to do this with Disk Utility.
Is that a bad idea? - Patrick, why do you say this should be done using the original boot disks?

best,
John
best,
John
Posted on Sun, Nov 28 2004 20:31
by Patrick Wilson
Joined on Mon, Feb 16 2004, UK, Posts 109
JohnA wrote:
It is possible to do this with Disk Utility.
Is that a bad idea? - Patrick, why do you say this should be done using the original boot disks?

best,
John


I don't think so. In Disk Utility, the drive which has the system on does not let me turn journaling off or on. I can switch journaling on all other connected drives but not the boot drive.
Posted on Mon, Nov 29 2004 17:03
by JohnA
Joined on Fri, Mar 28 2003, Dartmouth, Canada, Posts 161
Patrick Wilson wrote:
I don't think so. In Disk Utility, the drive which has the system on does not let me turn journaling off or on. I can switch journaling on all other connected drives but not the boot drive.

Hmm, it seems to have worked for me. For the moment I'm not noticing any undesired side-effects. I'm running 10.3.6 on a dual 1G G4.
And I have noticed a rather pleasant speed increase in VSL, well rather it doesn't cough and splutter so much when it's trying to "get used to" a big arrangement.

Fingers crossed,
John
best,
John
2 Pages12>
You cannot post new threads in this forum.
You cannot reply to threads in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.