Welcome Guest! To enable all features please Login or Register.

Notification

Icon
Error

Forum Jump  
LaCie 250 GB problems - any thoughts?
Last post Mon, Jun 21 2004 by plowman, 5 replies.
Options
Go to last post
Posted on Sat, Jun 12 2004 17:17
by Klaus
Joined on Tue, Oct 22 2002, Munich, Germany, Posts 17
About two weeks ago i bought several LaCie 250 GB HDs. Copied lots of data to them - also in big chuncks (some gigs in one run). Everything worked super so far. Had superb track count - no probs at all. All this in ProTools. With Logic i also did not have any prob.

But now i copied the ProEdition of the Vienna Lib and other Libs to two of these HDs. Worked also fine.

Then i found a EXS program/soundfile that made Logic crash (always!). Then i thought i reload that instrument from the DVD (it was the clarinet in b - normal set - not the performance one) - that also worked fine - then i wanted to erase the old instrument. Here is where the problem started. It seems that there is a problem to erase data from these drives... - complete crash of the mac without any message from the mac - just the spinning wheel... forever...

With another drive i copied 4 45 min films (dialogs, atmos, EFX, foley...) from a SCSI drive without a problem - they also played perfect - but then i wanted to erase/delete two of the folders with all the files in it and again - the mac crashes completely (spinning wheel forever...). I tried several restarts (pushing the power-button for some seconds - no other way possibal) - tried it again several times - just the same happens again...

Ran disc-util for disc-permissions and also for repair of the HDs - no problems found (used the apple utils).
Norton 8.02 or 8.2 (anyway the newest one) did find lots of problems - but i let Norton not repair anything (it also found lots of probs on the startup-drive - i dont trust Norton anymore - so Norton found probs - but i did not let him repair anything!!! - is it worth a try???)
The drives are connected via FW400 to the mac. The connection from one to the other drive is via FW 800 - but that does not matter, because i also tried it with just one drive attached... same results...

Next test was deleting some folders from the drives using my PowerBook G4 (with 10.3.4) - same thing - crashes. I can delete single files (on both systems) - but as soon i try to delet lots of files the problem begins...

This makes me nervous now - it took nearly a week just to import/write all the data to two of the drives (all these libraries are just too much data...)


Any ideas????


Mac 1GHz DP, OSX 10.3.2., 1,5 GB RAM, PT 6.4, HD-2, Logic Pro 6.4.1, new digi CoreAudioDriver, PowerBook G4, 1GB RAM...
Newes drivers from LaCie were already installed (i checked that)
Posted on Sat, Jun 12 2004 22:44
by cm
Joined on Fri, Dec 20 2002, vienna, Posts 9121
yes, i also don't trust norton anymore (maybe you remember many folks lost several disks with norton when osX came out?) before you try to repair anything make a backup or an image if you have the option _and_ check if it is restorable.
my feeling is too many guys are not testing their apps in real world situations - permission problems, file system issues to be found over the whole system ... possibly the principle of a B-tree has never been really understood?

one thing that disturbs me for a very long tome is that it is not possible to create primary partitions with HFS or HFS+ but only logical drives on extended partitions - why? this is the first single point of failure ...
christian
and remember: a CRAY is the only computer that runs an endless loop in just four hours ...
Posted on Mon, Jun 21 2004 09:53
by Klaus
Joined on Tue, Oct 22 2002, Munich, Germany, Posts 17
Found out what the problem was: Norton File Saver. Disabed it and the disks work perfect now. Norton seems to have (beside others) a problem with disks over a certain size (all my other disks did work fine - the biggest one was 80 GB).
Posted on Mon, Jun 21 2004 16:03
by jbm
Joined on Fri, Jan 16 2004, Posts 1159
Burn Norton's now. Buy a copy of Disk Warrior later. Wink

J.
Posted on Mon, Jun 21 2004 19:52
by plowman
Joined on Sat, Dec 13 2003, Posts 1128
Klaus, congrats on solving your problem. I'm glad it wasn't the LaCie 250 GB. It's been a great drive for me.
You cannot post new threads in this forum.
You cannot reply to threads in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.